Reply to bmnichol:
We went to the Club Amigo Carisol near Santiago.
Apparently there was extensive damage in the area caused by hurricane Dennis. I don't know if or when it will reopen.
It was billed as a 3.5*. We had a lovely time. It was very clean, the staff were great, the food was not fancy but we always found something we liked. For the price we paid we were very satisfied.