What do you folks think of San Andres Island and Panama? Both are predominantly hosted by Decameron hotels...seem to have decent reputations.
Heather, I noticed you've dabbled with the ider of San Andres. The colours of the ocean are pretty unique and while I'm hearing mixed feelings about beach quality, I think I could work with what I've seen! Prices are nuts lately, but a late April departure can get us to SAI for about $1200 pp all in, while Panama is running over $1300 base right now pp. Panama used to be the cheapest place on the planet...looks like tour operators are onto something!
Our other consideration is Mexico (Mayan) but we're limited by budget, and the only option at this time is the Bahia Principe Tulum.
Keen to hear other's comments!
Thanks